Chuckatuck

Brock Home

Brock House on Meadowlot Lane — Over 100 years old.


Chapman-Mason Home — c1810-1830 – 2 ½ story Federal style, 132 Kings Highway
This home is owned by Mr. and Mrs. Barry A. Mason. They renovated the house. Shortly after the turn of the century it was a boarding house for local teachers. It even housed a barber shop operated by the previous owners, the Chapmans.


Meador-Cannon Home — c1825-1850 – 2 ½ story Federal style, 120 Kings Highway


Richard C. Gilliam Home — The Gilliam house, to the right of the Knight house, was built in 1898 by Richard Claiborne Gilliam (Capt. “Busby”) and Mrs. Annie Lee Gilliam.  They were the parents of Annie, Carlyle, Ray, and Mary. They also raised his half-brother’s child, Oliver Gilliam. 
Ray Gilliam Home - Ray and his wife, Dot Gilliam, built a house to the right of his parents’ in 1916.


Pinner Home

Pinner Home — Over 100 years old on Route 10


butts-powell-saunders-home-img226.jpg

The Butts-Powell-Saunders Home

The Butts-Powell-Saunders Home — The original structure of the Butts-Powell-Saunders house was built ca. 1780-1820.  Dr. George Washington Butts bought the property at 133 Kings Highway as well as the Butts farm in Nansemond County, adjacent to the Pembroke Plantation.  He was born in Chuckatuck in 1843, the son of Edward A. and Mary Butts.  He graduated from the University of Virginia in 1860.  During the Civil War, he served with the 13th Virginia Cavalry.  Dr. Butts graduated from the Medical College of Virginia in 1868.  He practiced medicine in Chuckatuck and served as Treasurer of Nansemond County at one time.  The original Chuckatuck House, purchased by Dr. Butts, was a 1 ½-story dwelling with a side passage and two exterior chimneys.

In 1927, Z. H. Powell, who had married Dr. Butts’ daughter, Charlotte, extensively rebuilt the house in Chuckatuck, as well as most of the outbuildings.  The outbuildings comprise a small 2 ½-room office, an outside kitchen with a working fireplace, a smokehouse, a workshop, a woodshed, and a double garage.   The remodeled 19th-century house is 1 ½ stories of beaded wood construction and features a detailed wrap-around porch, an attached carport, and a large basement that dates back to the original structure.   There are two shoulder-end chimneys, one rear chimney, and two gabled dormers.  The plastered rooms are spacious and large, featuring two kitchens.  The Powells installed crown molding, beautiful chair railings, and hardwood oak flooring throughout the house.  The Powells were kind people and gave their employees fair opportunities.  They also owned a large clubhouse on the Butts Farm property where they held many social gatherings during the summer months.  They rode horses and were always “dressed up”.  They employed servants and a chauffeur.  Their son was George Butts Powell.

A water tank on the property held water pumped from a ram at the artesian well at Chuckatuck Creek. Approximately six homes were served with water from this source. Harvey Saunders maintained and kept the water tank system plant functioning.

The house was bought from the Powells by Robert B. Woods, who sold it to Harvey Saunders Sr. in 1946.  The property was still owned by the Saunders family in 2011.   Harvey Saunders Sr. was manager of the Butts farm, for Mr. Z.H. Powell, during the Depression, before he moved his family to Chuckatuck.  He worked for Lone Star Cement Co. until his retirement.  (pic of Godwin, Norfleet, Christopher, and Butts houses)

Jackie Saunders sources: Harvey F. Saunders, Jr., Library of Virginia (Jack Brady – U.S. Department of Interior, National Park Service –  National  Register of Historic Places – Works Progress Administration of Virginia – Historical Inventory),  Matsie Moore Savage,  Mildred Godwin Knight


Crumpler / Spady Home

Crumpler / Spady Home — When asked whether the Spady house had ever served as a hotel, Frank Spady, Jr. said it was once referred to as a hotel.  He remembers it being used for boarders by the Crumplers.  This 1 ½ story house was probably built in the early 1800s. (1820-1840)

The house and farm were once owned by Dr. Robert H. Tynes, who died owing a small debt.  His son, Robert H. Tynes, Jr., sold 1 ½ acres to pay the debt first.  The balance (“25 acres more or less”) was later sold on the Nansemond County Courthouse steps on 12-12-1898 for $1,525 to Lula E. (Crumpler) Pitt, grandmother of Frank Spady, Jr.  The property was bounded on the North by the “main road passing through Chuckatuck from Suffolk to Smithfield”, on the West by “Mrs. James E. Godwin’s heirs, also on the West “by Charles B. Godwin’s lands”, on the East by the “main road leading to Suffolk”, and on the South “by lands belonging to the free school and the Masonic Lodge”.  The deed was signed by Wilbur J. Kilby, Special Commissioner, on August 29, 1899.   It was also owned at one time by Charles B. Godwin.

Lula Crumpler Pitt was born on the Holladay Point farm.  The family lived in an earlier house located where Mills Godwin’s home place was.  Her father died in 1892.  Lula, her three children, and her brother Matt Crumpler moved to the Godwin-Knight home in 1892 and lived there until 1898, when they moved to the Spady house.  She took in boarders who worked in the area as well as travelers.  Lula transferred the house to her brother Matthew W. Crumpler soon after buying it.    Lula died in 1906.  Matthew W. Crumpler left the house to Frank A. Spady, Sr., who was married to Lula Pitt’s daughter, Maggie Pitt. The house was left to the three Spady children, Wilson, Frank, Jr., and Emma Mae.  Wilson was the last one to live there.  Following Wilson’s death, Frank sold his half to Emma Mae.


The Moore Home — Mr. William Charles Moore purchased an old grocery store on Kings Highway, Route 125, which is said to have been over 200 years old, as well as the property next to the store from a Captain Ramsey.  Mr. Moore worked for Captain Ramsey before he bought the store and the adjacent property.  He built a large Victorian two-story home, which was completed in 1909, on the land.   The construction of the house took 2 years to complete.  It was sold in the late 1940s to Corbell Cotten.  The house is now next to the U.S. Post Office, near the original site of the store.  The store served as the post office for a few years, with Alex Moore as the postmaster.

Jackie Saunders — To the right of the house, and approximately behind where the current post office is now, was a barn with stables that housed mules used to pull the road machines to keep the dirt roads passable.  Mr. Moore was on the Nansemond County Board of Supervisors for the Chuckatuck area.  The Board was responsible for maintaining the roads before they were taken over by the state and paved in approximately 1930.

Moore family history – Matsie Moore Savedge


Marshall / Bowden Home is the white building in the middle

Marshall / Bowden Home — Mrs. Molly Marshall, 1/2 sister to Charlie H. Pitt, lived in the house to the right of Spady’s garage.  Her daughter, Miss Lillian Marshall, was the librarian at Chuckatuck School for several years. Her other children were Wilber and Ruby.  While the date is not known, it is believed that this is the oldest house in the village.  Frank Spady remembers years ago when a Blair Brothers’ truck knocked the Marshall home off the foundation.  When the house was repaired, books related to a pharmacy located in Chuckatuck were found in the wall.


Godwin-Knight Home

Godwin-Knight Home — The following is from documentation prepared for the application to the National Register of Historic Places in January 1992 (the house was already listed on the Virginia Register of Historic Places at that time, due to its architectural significance), submitted by Sharon Krumpe.

The tract of land upon which the Godwin-Knight House stands was acquired by the Godwin family at least as early as the late 18th century, when Henry Godwin owned 441 acres in the vicinity of Chuckatuck.  In 1815, his estate was divided, and H.P. Godwin received 281 acres.  He sold the tract to Joseph Godwin in 1825, and Joseph, in turn, sold it to Jennette Godwin in 1834.  Jennette subdivided her property in 1856, selling off five adjoining lots, ranging in size from one acre to an acre and a half.  The lots were laid out on the eastern side of Chuckatuck, along present-day Route 125.  One of the purchasers was Edward F. Wicks.  He bought a 1 ½-acre lot and immediately built a 4-story, Federal-style, double-pile, three-bay, side-passage-plan frame dwelling.  Over the next two years, other lot owners built houses that closely resembled his.

Wicks owned the property until 1861, when he sold it to Henry L. Tynes.  Tynes sold the tract in 1867 to Annie Glover; thereafter, the property changed hands several times until Lulie E. Pitt acquired it in 1897 from Matthew W. Crumpler.  Pitt sold it the following year to Charles B. Godwin, and about 1900, Godwin carried out the Queen Anne-style alterations to the house.  Godwin added a tower, wrap-around porch, encaustic tile vestibule, plaster embellishments in the front parlor, mantels, woodwork, stained glass windows, and stairs typical of the period.

Godwin lived in the house until he sold it in 1925 to his nephew, Mills Edwin Godwin, Sr. This Godwin, a farmer and member of the Nansemond County School Board and the Board of Supervisors, moved his family into the house in the fall of 1927.  Among his family were four children, including Mills E Godwin, Jr., and Mildred Elizabeth Godwin.  The younger Mills Godwin lived in the house until his marriage to Katherine Thomas Beale in 1940.  Upon the death of the elder Mills Godwin in 1946, the house passed to his daughters, Mildred Godwin Knight and Leah Godwin Keith, upon his death.  Mrs. Knight purchased her sister’s share in the property.  Paul and Sharon Wilson Krumpe bought the house from Mrs. Knight in August 1992.

As a member of the Board of Supervisors, Mr. Godwin was responsible for maintaining and repairing dirt roads.  The barn is still standing where he kept the mules and equipment used for this purpose.


 

Everets

Kirk Home

Kirk Home — J.J. Kirk lived in an outside building when he moved to Everets in 1871.   In addition to running a sawmill, he also had a box factory and later made baskets.  In 1875, he married Margaretta Godwin, whom he had met at St. John’s Episcopal Church.  The Kirk house was not complete when they married, and they lived with the Minton’s for 5 or 6 months, spending their wedding night there.   The new house contained a kitchen and dining area in the basement.  The first floor had a living room and one bedroom.  The second floor had two bedrooms.  The house was heated by stoves, and a furnace in the basement supplied heat to the first floor.  Their three children, Elizabeth, Russell, and Paul, were born at Everets.  In approximately 1880, an addition was constructed, changing the functions of the original rooms.  This addition contained a dining room, kitchen and two bedrooms.  In 1904, Margaretta convinced John J. to move to Port Norfolk so she could be near her sister, Betty G. Corbell.  Willie Saunders and his wife then leased the Kirk house and lived there when W.G. was born in 1905.  They later built a house across the road.  The Kirk house was vacant for a few years, and the Kirks would come back for the summer by cart or, mainly, by boat from Port Norfolk.  Russell and Stokes moved back in 1924 when Russell went into the cotton ginning business and later the lumber business.  Merle and Arthur came in 1925.  It must have been difficult to leave indoor plumbing and electricity!  Another addition was made in 1950, at which time the 1880 addition was rolled on logs to its present location on Kirk Road.  In 1979, Bruce Kirk, the current owner, completed the renovation of the part that was initially built in 1875.


Joyner home

Sandy Ridge-Joyner Home — “This old house stands like a sentinel just within the Isle of Wight County line on Everets Road.  It was probably built by a Godwin or a Lawrence before the Revolutionary War.  Robert Lawrence, Jr., was living there at the time of his death in 1807.  It was sold by Thomas Lawrence to Abraham D. Jones in 1832.  Between 1832 and 1881, the property was owned by numerous individuals, including some absentee landlords.  The William Dews family owned it from 1836 to 1851.  In 1881, the 519-acre plantation was bought by George M. Gay of Nansemond.  After his death, his widow, who had remarried, was entitled to her dower, which included the old house.  Her name then was Mattie M. Wills.  Some of the older generations around here remember the old Wills’ couple sitting on the porch.  After the death of Mattie M. Wills, W. G. Saunders acquired the land and then sold it to T. J. Saunders, who, in turn, sold it to DeWitt Griffin and W. T. Joyner of Windsor.  It was used as a tenant house for years.”  The house, with its huge chimneys and Dutch roof, was restored by Alva and Weyland Joyner III in 2000.

Quoted from Historic Isle of Wight County by Helen Haverty King, 2007


Martin home 2.jpg

Martin Home — According to the “Virginia Works Progress Administration of Virginia Historical Inventory” conducted in 1937, this farm was bought by John G. Martin, a native of Germany, in approximately 1840.  The report states that Mr. Martin “came to America and bought this farm and built the home.  He left his home about 1859, thinking that he would escape the War Between the States, and went north, taking with him the deed for the place; but the Federal Army drafted him, and he had to serve.  After the War, he returned home to find someone else living in his house.  In the meantime, or during the War Between the States, the courthouse at the county seat had been burned, and the man in possession could not show any deed.  Mr. Martin, having saved his deed and a new clerk’s office having been built, at once took his deed to the clerk’s office and had it recorded.  It so happened that his was the first deed in the new clerk’s office – Deed #1, Page #1, Book #1.  The party who had taken possession of the place had to vacate.” The farm was inherited by John G. Martin’s son, John E. Martin, who left it to his widow, Mrs. Sallie Martin.  John Atlee Martin was born here in 1892.  He and his wife, Mary, raised their son, Earl, in this area.  Atlee farmed the land until 1959 when he opened a general store at Everets, the former Wagner’s store.  Earl married in 1962, lived in Chuckatuck, and then returned to the farm in February 1973, raising the fifth generation of Martins on this family farm.


Pruden Home — The Pruden Farm, located at 21329 Quaker Road, adjacent to Lake Burnt Mills, is an intact farm complex dating back to the first half of the 19th century, comprising the house, a kitchen, a smokehouse, slave quarters, and three log cribs (barns). This was the home of Nathaniel Pruden Sr., who was born in 1763 and died in 1836.  He inherited the property from his father, also named Nathaniel.  The property was owned by several members of the Pruden Family during the 19th century and was acquired by Reginald Pruden and his wife, Sallie Atkins, early in the 20th century.  It remained the home and working farm of Reginald and his son, Brooklyn, and Brooklyn’s wife, Doris Stagg Pruden, throughout the 20th century.  The nieces and a nephew of Doris Stagg Pruden owned it in 2012.

Research by the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, using tax records, dates the earliest story-and-a-half portion of the house (and the kitchen) to 1821-1822.  Two-and-a-half stories were added in the 1830s, causing one end chimney to be relocated to the side of the new portion to allow for passage, on the first floor only, between the two sections.  There are two stepped-shoulder chimneys in the 1:3 bond typical of the period.  The interior is finished in the plain late Federal manner, featuring paneled wainscoting, nine-over-nine windows, wide-board floors, and two stairways, one of which is an interior winder.

The outbuildings remain largely intact, retaining their original features, although some beams and bricks have been repurposed over the years.   One original outbuilding – a small stilted dairy or milk house – was lost to a storm in 1990.

From Betty Stagg, niece of Mrs. Pruden

e


T.J. Saunders, Jr. Home — According to the oldest Saunders’ grandchild, Mary Way, this house was built in the mid-1880s from heart pine cut on the property.  Mr. Saunders had a sawmill on the farm, as did many large farmers.  Looking out their back windows in 1900, the family could have seen the western branch of the Nansemond River, one of the two stores, the Wagner home, the Kirk home, the baptismal area, the Kirk sawmill, as well as the bridge, warehouses, and loading docks along the shore.  The house with 14’ ceilings had carbide lights.  You could cut a tube in each room to let in carbide from the building where it was produced.  The house was sold in c1938 to Weyland T. Joyner of Windsor.  Mr. Joyner sold the house in 1947 to Alfred and Emma Russell, who made extensive renovations.  While Mr. and Mrs. Russell had no children of their own, they welcomed young people, including many nieces and nephews, into their home.  After the death of Mr. and Mrs. Russell, the house was purchased in 1988 by Dr. and Mrs. Arthur L. Chambers, III.  They renovated the home in 1993 to better suit their family, which included three daughters.  The Chambers family sold this beautiful home in 201?.


Minton Home — The Minton house was once owned by Claude T. Minton and may have been built by him. The property was sold by his grandson, Judge George Franklin Whitley, Jr. of Smithfield, to J. R. Kirk in 1948.  Hinton Harry Schramm and his wife, Elizabeth Cotton Schramm, moved from Franklin to the Minton house in 1929 and lived there until 1951.  They rented the house from the Minton, Whitley, and Kirk families.  The Schramms had two daughters, Mildred and Eunice.  Mr. Schramm passed away in 1950, and Mrs. Schramm relocated to Newport News to live with her daughter, Mildred, and son-in-law, W. C. Dailey.  Sometime after 1951, the first floor was raised above ground level, and the house was converted into two apartments.  Eunice remembers five tenant houses on the farm.  There was a house to the left of the Minton house in the orchard.  This is where “Uncle” John Riddick lived.  He fed the livestock and performed some night watch duty at the sawmill.  Other people who lived there were George, Sophia, Willie, Sammy, Eunice, Willie Riddick, Mrs. Bartley or Bartlett, and later Will and Carrie Bush, who resided in a house on the lot adjacent to the Minton house.


 

Exit / Exeter

Phillips-Saunders Home

Phillips-Saunders Home — Located in Exit, this Greek revival house at the intersection of Lake Prince Drive and Exeter Drive is known as Exeter Place.  Edwin E. and Almedia Hancock Phillips acquired the farm from Joseph Scott in approximately 1825.  Mr. and Mrs. Phillips built the present house.  There is a story about an earlier brick house being torn down “because numerous infants had died of a fever, as well as older people, and it was declared unsafe for habitation.  This was passed down from two former slaves who remained at Exeter after the war – Uncle Andrew Hawkins and Aunt Anna Todd.”  The Phillips’ daughter, Mary Anna, ran the farm during the Civil War.  The plantation was once used as a headquarters by Union cavalry forces and also served as a hospital.  After the war, she married Sydney Trexvant Ellis, who farmed and managed the land.   They had two children, Edwin Sydney Ellis and Almedia Hancock Ellis.  Edwin Sydney raised his family of three children, Ann, Emil, and “Trez”, there until 1937 when the depression caused the 325.75 acres to be sold at auction for $10,000.  (2)

The house and farm were bought by Thomas J. Saunders, III, and his wife, Elizabeth, who raised their daughter, Mary Ainslie, in the beautiful Greek revival home.  They operated a “truck farm” there, growing sweet potatoes, corn, peanuts, and other crops Tommy would sell in area markets.  A white picket fence with unique free-swinging gates surrounded the beautiful home.  The farm property was sold in 1979 and developed into “Lake Prince Meadows”.  The house and lot have been passed through several owners, including Mr. and Mrs. Glenn Moore, who painted beautiful murals in several rooms. 


 

Longview

Brock / Oliver Home

Brock / Oliver Home — The Oliver home at Longview was built by the Joel Brock family about 1900.  One of Joel Brock’s sons, Clinton Brock, owned the Oliver farm during the early part of the Depression.  Later, the Royster Guano Company rented the farm land to tenant farmers, including the Jeremiah Oliver family. Jesse, Junie, Johnnie, Thomas, Allie, Ralph, Rae Parker, Bennie, Frank, Emma Mae, Ethel, and Lottie were the twelve Oliver children.  In approximately 1937, after Jeremiah's death, Jesse Oliver purchased the farm and house where he had raised his family.  The Oliver family still owns it.


Horne / Wilson Home

Horne / Wilson Home — Mrs. Shirley Horne Wilson was born in this house in Longview.  Her father, Waverly Horne, bought the property in 1922 from Charlie Lawrence.  This former Brock home, built around 1840, featured a living room and bedroom on the first floor, as well as two rooms upstairs.  The kitchen and dining room were separated from the bedrooms and living room by a colonnade and porch.  Mr. Horne remodeled the house in 1937.  Mrs. Wilson bought her family’s home place on Longview Drive in approximately 1988.  Her parents once operated a store located in the corner of the lot towards the intersection.


 

Oakland

Pembroke

Pembroke — Near Chuckatuck overlooking the Nansemond River, is the handsome brick home known as Pembroke, which was built in 1701 by an English seaman, “Captain” Jack, who named the estate for the Earl of Pembroke.   The property was a grant from the King of England, approximately 650 acres, which stretched from the Nansemond River to Reid’s Ferry.   Captain Jack mysteriously disappeared, and his caretaker, Patrick Wilkinson, obtained the estate.  His descendants owned the land until 1830 when it was purchased by James Hunter Godwin.

The estate was occupied by many before Mr. and Mrs. Frank Warrington purchased the land in 1940 from Horace Philips of North Carolina.  The property consisted of approximately 330 acres.  The  Warringtons found that the house was selected and listed in the Library of Congress as possessing exceptional historic and architectural interest and being worthy of careful preservation for the benefit of future generations.   The house is one of two remaining U-shaped pre-revolutionary houses in the United States.

During the War of 1812, the British burned the house, destroying much of the interior woodwork.   Bullet holes from the Civil War are visible, and cannon balls were found in the façade facing the Nansemond River.

Restoration by the Warringtons was conducted from 1950 to 1952, and today, the home is a beautiful example with its original features preserved for the most part. George W. Lewis, a colonial restoration builder, was contracted to restore Pembroke. Mrs. Frank Warrington carefully chose the period pieces for the furnishings.

The estate was inherited in 1990 by Mrs. Marshall (Jean) Cox from her aunt, Mrs. Myrtle Warrington.   In 2011, the estate was beautifully maintained by Mrs. Cox, a gracious lady, who cherishes her home.   The estate also contains the homes of Jean Cox’s two sons and daughter.

Jackie Saunders Sources:   Mrs. Marshall (Jean) Cox –   Richmond Times Dispatch –   Suffolk News-Herald,  April 17, 1955   –   1930 Work Project Administration-   HABS No. Va.. 181 –    Friday Morning, Vol.XXIII , March 6, 1818


T.A. Saunders Home


 

Sandy Bottom

Cotton Home

Cotton Home — At the end of what is now Cotton Farm Lane, there lived the family of John Corbell, a large landowner in the late 1800s.  Little is known about the fate of the original Corbell home, yet we do know that a new structure was built around 1900.  From this original site, we understand that a part of a building or a small building was moved approximately 200 feet away to make room for a new dwelling.  The building that was moved was added to and remodeled.  It is today the home of Mrs. Elsie Copeland, daughter-in-law of the earlier owners, W. G. and Grace Copeland.  Due to its construction and materials, it is perhaps one of the oldest homes in the area.

From the research and conversations with Eddie Cotten, who lived on the Cotten farm, the small house was located in the area of the big house and was the first home of John David and Elizabeth Mary Corbell.  It was later the home of the David Corbell Cotten family.  As the children started coming every two years, the little house was relocated to its current location, and the big house was constructed where it stands today.  Mrs. Copeland is still living in that smaller home, which has several additions.  In place of the old Corbell home, a new home was constructed circa 1900 or earlier. 2025 update - Mrs. Elsie Copeland has since died and her small home has been torn down.


Cowling-Pope Farm Home — The Pope house currently standing was built in 1869.  John Henry Powell, father of Annie Powell (married Leroy Pope, Sr.), rented the farm before the Popes bought it.  The kitchen and dining room on the Pope farm were separate from the main house.  The house was renovated in 1949, when the plumbing, kitchen, and other amenities were added.  Leroy Pope related that he and his brother James are fifth-generation owners.  James was living in the old home place on Chuckatuck Creek in 2015.   This is possibly the oldest home in the Sandy Bottom area.  There were also tenant homes on the property that may have been used as homes for slaves.


Crooked Creek Home


Henry Pruden Farm Home

Henry Pruden Farm Home — Henry Pruden, great-grandfather of Deborah Pruden Powell, bought the farm in 1882 from John Baker and built the house for his family of two adults and six children. It was a classic “two on two” house with a wide hall downstairs, two rooms, and small box rooms upstairs. The kitchen was a separate building and sat to the side of the main house.  An original house was moved to the property and torn down in the early fifties.

The new house, built in approximately 1900, had no plumbing or central heating. Each room had a fireplace flush with the wall, and the chimneys were built outside the house. There were small porches on the front and back of the house. The porch facing the Chuckatuck Creek was decorated with numerous curlicues and gingerbread trim, while the porch facing the lane was plain. The house was constructed of pegs and square-headed nails; the walls were lathened with mud between the slats and covered with rough horsehair plaster. The stairs were narrow and steep.

The outside of the house was covered with broad, rough wood planks. The windows were classic six-on-six, which did not fit well.  The roof was tin.  At some point, a breezeway was built between the house and the kitchen. A pantry was added to the kitchen, and the front porch was extended across the kitchen. Later, the breezeway was enclosed, and the room was used as a dining room.

Henry’s daughter, Ethel, and her husband, Stanley, moved into the farmhouse in 1916 after the death of her father and mother.  Stanley took over the farm. Their children, Wilson and Vernell, were both born there.  The old house fell into disrepair during the depression.  When Wilson Pruden married in 1946, he renovated the house and moved back in with his wife and mother in 1947.  In 1946, electricity was introduced to the farm, and the dining room was converted into a bathroom with indoor plumbing. An electric heater, a sink with running water, and a gas cook stove were put in the kitchen.  Ethel stayed on the farm until 1953, when she permanently moved back to Norfolk with her daughter. Ethel died in 1958.

The house had sheltered four generations of Prudens before it was sold, along with the farm, in 1966 to Dr. Louis Waters.  Dr. Waters expanded the kitchen, added a bedroom, and created a bathroom. His son, Louis Waters, Jr., and his wife, Debbie, now own the home. In 2010, they undertook extensive renovations, including a large great room, a gourmet kitchen, and a spa bathroom.

Deborah Pruden Powell


 

Wills’ Corner / Cherry Grove Road

Godwin - Lawrence - Barlow home (Cotton Plains) — The house was built in the 1780s, with good evidence that it was constructed in 1784 by John Godwin.  The architectural style is a transition from Colonial to Federal.  The Lawrence family owned the house for most of the 1800s, and the surrounding farm has been known as “Cotton Plains” since their time there.  Joseph and Shelley Barlow started the reconstruction of the house in 1996 and moved in 2000.

The majority of the floors, windows, hinges, and woodwork are original to the house.  The house had not been occupied for at least 60 years before the renovation and had never had electricity or plumbing.  The house originally had two chimneys with six working fireplaces, which were removed, probably in the 1940s, and replaced with a central chimney to accommodate coal stoves.

The main hall would have served many purposes in the 1800s.  This 30-foot-long passage, with the large front and back doors open for ventilation, would have served as a work area in the summertime.  The front and rear doors, featuring glass transoms above, are original to the house.  The double doors are typical of this period.  Since final arrangements for loved ones were typically handled by families at home, it’s thought that the wide passage was intended to facilitate the movement of coffins in and out of the house.

The parlor, the largest and most formal room in the house, would have been used for multiple purposes, including business meetings, entertaining guests, and various household chores, such as spinning.  Artifacts found in the house during the renovation include a broken pane of glass with the signature of John Godwin and a date of May 1784, a flint-lock pistol with powder horn, a child’s shoe, the bottom of a wine bottle, an ink well, and other items.  Names etched on an old window in the Lawrence home are those of:

  • Virginia G. Galt

  • Cornela Riddick – 1837

  • Cornela Blunt

  • Rick H. Riddick 

  • Elisha Ann Jennings – 1837

The current kitchen was originally a dining room used by the family for everyday meals.  The small door to the left of the sink was likely used to pass food and firewood into the room from outside.  The original kitchen was a separate building located approximately where the grape arbor is today.  There is evidence from old letters that Elizabeth Lawrence used this room as her bedroom in her old age and that the family used another dining room located in the basement during this time.

A 2000 addition on the back replaced a 1940s addition that included a small room and a back porch.  Every effort was made to take advantage of the beautiful horseshoe view of the Chuckatuck Creek.  Cotton Plains Farm borders the Chuckatuck Creek and is part of a peninsula of land given initially in a land grant to the Godwin family.

The upstairs was originally four bedrooms, two with fireplaces and two without.  In the 1800s, this space would have served as the sleeping quarters for Robert and Elizabeth Lawrence and their three sons and three daughters.  It is believed that a door in this room opened to an addition, possibly added to accommodate Sarah Lawrence Godwin, who moved back to her parents’ home with her children after the death of her husband.  Her signature can be seen on two doors in these rooms.


Jack Whitehead Home — The Whitehead house was built around 1858 on what is now Oliver Drive.  It was sold out of the Whitehead family in 1923.  After changing hands several times, it was bought in 1942 by Herbert C. Hall of the “Anchorage”.  It was passed down to his grandson, Cornelius Hall Duff.  The square-frame house with an English basement features a side passage on the west end.  Two massive chimneys are located on the east end of the house.

 From Historic Isle of Wight County by Helen Haverty King, 2007


The Anchorage — The Anchorage, built in 1695 by Thomas Godwin, sitting off Cherry Grove Road, has had two additions.  In the 1700s, a double-decker porch was added to the back of the house, and in the 1900s, a two-story frame addition was added.  The plaster in the house contains seashells and horse hair in its composition.  The three-story brick farmhouse, constructed with brick made on-site, is situated on a 300-acre tract.  It features massive twin chimneys, and the molded wedge-shaped bricks form the round brick pillars.  Some of the glass panes in the windows, the window frames, and the door hardware are imported from England. Thomas Godwin was given the land by his father, who lived further down Cherry Grove Road at “The Castle”.  Both men served in the House of Burgesses.  A school was once located here.

The home is now owned by Cornelius and Annie Lee Duff, who moved in in 1961. Duff’s great-grandfather, Cornelius Hall, bought The Anchorage in 1845 from a man named Day. The home has been continually occupied for 300 years. Today, the house with 12-foot ceilings has more than 20 living areas, including two kitchens and six fireplaces.

Compiled by Jackie Saunders, The Suffolk Sun, October 25, 1990


Phillips Farm Home — The Phillips Farm House, located on Godwin Boulevard near Wills Corner, was built circa 1820 by John T. and Elizabeth Underwood Phillips. The house was built on a high ridge called the Suffolk Escarpment overlooking what was originally a stagecoach route to Richmond. The Phillips Farm was originally 184 acres bequeathed to John T. Phillips by his father, John Phillips. Initially, a one-and-a-half-story house built on an English basement was doubled in size in 1948.  Phillips Farm House is one of 14 clerestory houses constructed between the Blackwater and Nansemond Rivers in Isle of Wight and Nansemond Counties, designed with contiguous clerestory windows across one façade of the house.  These houses were designed to replicate the window styles of New England textile mills and were built during the era when cotton was king in the South.  The Phillip Farm House is considered the best-preserved house of the original clerestory houses. It is listed on the Virginia Register of Historic Homes.

John T. and Elizabeth U. Phillips married in 1827 and had four children: John Theophilus Phillips, who became a doctor, James Jasper Phillips who was a colonel in the Civil War, Elizabeth Mary Phillips who married John David Corbell and was the mother of Sallie (LaSalle) Phillips who married General George Pickett of Civil War fame, and Sarah (Sallie) Ann Phillips who married James Eley.  These heirs of John T. and Elizabeth sold the farm in 1868.  The Phillips Farm was sold many times over the years, with some owners continuing to reside there.  Edwin and Carolyn Bickham purchased the house in 1978 and lovingly restored the entire house. It was sold by the Bickhams in 2022.

By Carolyn Bickham